301 vs 302 vs 307 vs 308 redirects is not simply a developer preference. The selected status tells clients whether a move is permanent or temporary and can also affect how non-GET requests are repeated at the destination.
Google Search Central recently revisited the distinction in its redirect explainer. For SEO teams, the useful response is a disciplined audit: confirm the business intent, choose the correct status, map every source to a relevant destination and test the complete path before launch.
What each redirect status communicates
Google’s redirect documentation groups 301 and 308 as permanent redirects. Googlebot follows them and the indexing pipeline uses them as a strong signal that the target should become canonical. Google groups 302 and 307 as temporary redirects; it follows them but does not use the redirect itself as a canonicalisation signal.
That does not make temporary redirects harmful. They are appropriate when the original URL should remain the long-term address, such as a short maintenance window, time-limited operational route or temporary service substitution.
| Status | Meaning | Method behaviour | Typical use |
|---|---|---|---|
| 301 | Moved permanently | A user agent may change POST to GET | Permanent page, path or domain change |
| 302 | Found; treated as temporary | A user agent may change POST to GET | Short-lived alternate destination |
| 307 | Temporary redirect | Method and body must not be changed | Temporary API, form or method-sensitive route |
| 308 | Permanent redirect | Method and body must not be changed | Permanent method-sensitive route change |
The HTTP Semantics standard defines these method-handling differences. For ordinary page-to-page GET navigation, 301 and 308 are both permanent choices, while 302 and 307 are temporary. Forms, APIs and uploads require extra care because replaying a request incorrectly can change or duplicate an action.
Step 1: Document why the URL is changing
Write a one-sentence reason for every redirect group. Is the old page permanently replaced, temporarily unavailable, consolidated into another resource or removed without an equivalent? The answer should determine the status and destination rather than allowing a CMS default to decide.
Do not redirect simply because a URL is old. If no closely relevant replacement exists, a 404 or 410 can be more accurate than sending users to the homepage. Kayaar’s content consolidation checklist explains how to distinguish merging, differentiation, retirement and canonicalisation.
Step 2: Build a one-to-one redirect map
Create a controlled sheet with the old URL, proposed destination, status code, reason, owner, dependencies and test result. Include URLs from XML sitemaps, analytics, Search Console, server logs, backlinks, campaigns and the CMS. Add images, PDFs and other files that receive traffic or links.
Map each source to the closest equivalent destination. Avoid sending many unrelated URLs to one page. The destination should satisfy the same task or clearly continue the user journey. When the path structure is also changing, use Kayaar’s SEO URL structure audit to check case, parameters, folders and preferred formats.
Check marketing dependencies before approval. Paid ads, email templates, QR codes, form actions, feeds, API clients and saved customer links may rely on the old route. A technically correct redirect can still break measurement or a transaction.
Step 3: Choose between the paired codes
For a permanent content-page move reached with GET, 301 is widely supported and normally the simplest choice. A 308 can express the same permanence while requiring the client to preserve the request method and body. Use it when that distinction is understood and supported by the full delivery stack.
For a temporary page route, 302 is common. Use 307 when the client must repeat the same method and body at the temporary destination. Never assume a browser, CDN, reverse proxy, cache, plugin and application will handle every code identically; test the actual production path.
Do not change permanent redirects to temporary ones to “protect rankings.” Choose the status that truthfully represents the move. Google states that permanent redirects do not cause a loss of PageRank, although significant migrations can still produce temporary search fluctuations while URLs are recrawled and processed.
Step 4: Test before release
Request a representative set of old URLs without automatically following redirects. Record the first status and Location header, then follow the path and confirm that the final page returns a successful response. Test desktop and mobile routes, uppercase variants, parameters, trailing slashes and protocol or hostname versions.
Check for chains and loops. An old URL should ideally redirect directly to its final destination, not pass through several historical addresses. Chains add latency and create more points of failure. Update internal links, canonical tags, hreflang, structured data and XML sitemaps to reference the final URL directly.
For forms or APIs, use a safe test environment and a non-destructive request. Confirm whether the method, body, authentication and parameters arrive intact. Do not test live payments, bookings or customer records merely to validate a redirect.
Step 5: Run post-launch SEO checks
After launch, crawl the old list and compare every response with the approved map. Verify that destinations are indexable, self-canonical and not blocked by robots rules. Check server logs and Search Console for unexpected 404s, redirect errors, soft 404 patterns and continued requests to obsolete addresses.
Track important landing pages, conversions and customer journeys rather than watching rankings alone. For a broader release, Kayaar’s website relaunch SEO sign-off adds ownership, staging and launch controls. If infrastructure also changes, apply the separate checks in the CDN migration audit.
Keep permanent redirects in place long enough for users, crawlers and external links to adapt. Update high-value internal and external links where possible, but do not remove a working redirect merely because the sitemap has changed.
Practical redirect audit checklist
- State whether every move is permanent, temporary or a genuine removal.
- Map each source URL to a closely relevant final destination.
- Select method-preserving 307 or 308 where the request requires it.
- Test status, Location header, final response, parameters and mobile behaviour.
- Remove chains and update internal links, canonicals and sitemaps.
- Monitor crawl errors, indexation and qualified outcomes after release.
For an independent redirect or migration review, contact Kayaar with an anonymised URL sample and the intended change. Never send passwords, private customer data or unrestricted production exports.
FAQs
What is the SEO difference between 301 and 302 redirects?
A 301 signals a permanent move and supports canonicalisation to the destination, while a 302 signals that the move is temporary.
Are 308 redirects treated like 301 redirects by Google?
Yes. Google documents 301 and 308 as permanent redirects, although their HTTP method-handling semantics differ.
When should a 307 redirect be used?
Use 307 for a temporary move when the client must preserve the original request method and body at the destination.
Should deleted pages redirect to the homepage?
Not by default. Use a closely relevant replacement, or return 404 or 410 when no suitable successor exists.
How should redirect chains be fixed?
Update each old source to point directly to the final destination, then replace internal links that still use intermediate URLs.









